Published in November 2026.
A disagreement between shareholders, or between the shareholders and the manager, can paralyse a company: blocked decisions, accounts left unapproved, projects on hold. French law offers tools to prevent these situations and to resolve them when they arise.
Prevention: articles of association and shareholders’ agreement
The best protection is built upstream, while the shareholders still get along. The articles of association and the shareholders’ agreement may provide in particular for:
- an approval clause, to control the entry of new shareholders;
- a pre-emption right, allowing existing shareholders to buy any shares sold in priority;
- an exclusion clause, available notably in the SAS, setting out the grounds and procedure;
- suitable majority and governance rules, especially where the capital is split equally;
- an exit mechanism in case of deadlock, such as a buy-sell clause between shareholders;
- a share valuation method, so that a disagreement over price does not prolong the dispute.
The main types of litigation
Abuse of minority or equality. Conversely, a minority or equal shareholder may block a decision essential to the company, in their own interest only. The court cannot vote in their place, but it can appoint a representative to vote on their behalf in the company’s interest (Cour de cassation, 9 March 1993, Flandin ruling).
Abuse of majority. Under a definition settled since a French Supreme Court (Cour de cassation) ruling of 18 April 1961, there is abuse where a decision is taken against the company’s interest, with the sole aim of favouring the majority shareholders to the detriment of the minority. A common example: systematically retaining profits without justification, while the majority shareholders pay themselves in other ways. The decision may be annulled and damages awarded.
Deadlock. Where the normal running of the company has become impossible and it faces imminent danger, the court may appoint a provisional administrator. This remains an exceptional measure. In the most serious cases, a disagreement between shareholders that paralyses the company may justify its judicial dissolution (article 1844-7, 5° of the Civil Code).
Management audit. Minority shareholders who have questions about a management decision may ask the court to appoint an expert to report on it (article L. 223-37 of the Commercial Code for the SARL and article L. 225-231 for the SA). This is often a useful first lever to obtain information.
Removal of the manager. The rules depend on the legal form: in an SARL, a manager removed without just cause may obtain damages (article L. 223-25 of the Commercial Code); in an SAS, the articles of association set the conditions for removal. In all cases, an abrupt or humiliating removal may be sanctioned.
Liability of managers. Shareholders may bring an action against a manager for mismanagement or a breach of the articles of association or of the law, either to obtain compensation for their own loss or on behalf of the company (article L. 223-22 of the Commercial Code for the SARL, articles L. 225-251 and L. 225-252 for the SA, applicable to the SAS by reference under article L. 227-8).
Exit of a shareholder and share valuation. Exclusion (provided for by the articles of association in an SAS, article L. 227-16 of the Commercial Code), withdrawal or compulsory buy-out always raise the question of price. In the event of disagreement, and in the cases provided for by law or by the articles of association, the price may be set by an expert appointed by the parties or by the court (article 1843-4 of the Civil Code).
Act early
A dispute between shareholders is best dealt with before it blocks the company. A prompt review of the articles of association, the shareholders’ agreement and the decisions at issue makes it possible to weigh the options: negotiating an exit, going to court, or seeking urgent measures. A negotiated solution is preferred whenever it serves the client’s interests.
